Are you stressing about getting letters of recommendation for your graduate school applications? Take a deep breath—you’re in the right place. At The Art of Applying®, we’ve helped thousands of Wild Card applicants navigate this process successfully, and today we’re sharing our proven strategies to help you secure strong letters that will enhance your application.
🎯 Why Letters of Recommendation Matter
Think of your application as a story, with you as the main character. While your essays tell your story from your perspective, recommendation letters add powerful supporting voices that validate your narrative. They provide external proof of your capabilities, achievements, and potential—something admissions committees value deeply.
📋 Understanding the Basic Requirements
Before diving into strategy, let’s clarify what different programs typically require:
Policy Schools (HKS, SIPA, etc.):
- Usually require three letters
- At least one should be academic
- Others can be professional or community service-related
Business Schools (HBS, Stanford GSB, etc.):
- Typically require two letters
- Current or recent supervisor preferred
- Second letter often from former supervisor
Law Schools:
- Generally require two letters
- Academic letters often preferred
- Professional letters also accepted
Special Note for MBA Consortium Applicants:
- Need a letter specifically endorsing your alignment with the consortium’s mission
- Should demonstrate your commitment to diversity and inclusion
🎯 The Art of Choosing the Right Recommenders
Here’s a truth that might surprise you: a glowing letter from your direct supervisor who knows your work intimately is far more valuable than a lukewarm letter from a CEO who barely knows you.
When selecting recommenders, prioritize:
1. Depth of relationship over title
2. Recent interaction over past connections
3. Ability to speak specifically about your achievements
4. Willingness to invest time in writing a strong letter
Red Flags to Avoid:
- Choosing someone solely for their impressive title
- Selecting recommenders who haven’t seen your work firsthand
- Picking someone who seems hesitant or too busy
- Waiting until the last minute to ask
💡 How to Approach Potential Recommenders
The way you ask for a recommendation can significantly impact the quality of the letter you receive. Here’s our proven approach:
Step 1: Make the Initial Ask
- Schedule a brief meeting or call
- Explain your graduate school plans
- Share why you’ve chosen them specifically
- Ask if they feel comfortable writing a strong, positive letter
Sample Script:
I’ve really valued our working relationship, and I’m applying to [program name]. Would you feel comfortable writing a strong letter of recommendation for me? I’d be happy to provide any materials that would make the process easier for you.
📝 Setting Your Recommenders Up for Success
Once someone agrees to write your letter, your job isn’t done—it’s just beginning. Here’s how to make their job easier and increase the chances of getting a stellar letter:
Create a Comprehensive Recommender Packet
Include:
- Your updated resume
- Personal statement or statement of purpose draft
- Key achievements and contributions they’ve witnessed
- Specific examples of your leadership and initiative
- Deadline information and submission instructions
- Brief overview of the program and why you’re applying
Pro Tip: Create a simple one-page document highlighting 3-4 specific situations or projects where you demonstrated skills relevant to your target programs.
⏰ Managing Timelines and Follow-up
Timing is everything when it comes to recommendations. Here’s your timeline for success:
3-4 Months Before Deadline:
- Make initial requests
- Send recommender packets
- Confirm their commitment
6-8 Weeks Before Deadline:
- Send friendly check-in email
- Offer additional information if needed
- Confirm they received all necessary links/forms
2-3 Weeks Before Deadline:
- Send gentle reminder
- Express gratitude
- Confirm they’re on track
🎯 Program-Specific Strategies
Different programs value different aspects of your recommendations. Here’s how to tailor your approach:
For MBA Programs:
- Focus on leadership examples
- Highlight team management skills
- Showcase business impact
- Include quantifiable results
For Policy Schools:
- Emphasize public service commitment
- Highlight policy analysis skills
- Showcase cross-sector collaboration
- Include community impact
For Law Schools:
- Focus on analytical abilities
- Highlight writing skills
- Showcase ethical judgment
- Include research capabilities
💌 The Art of Gratitude
After your recommenders submit their letters, showing appreciation isn’t just polite—it’s strategic. Here’s why:
- Maintains professional relationships
- Opens doors for future opportunities
- Creates goodwill for potential updates or additional letters
- Reflects your professional maturity
Ways to Show Appreciation:
- Send a handwritten thank-you note
- Offer to treat them to coffee or lunch
- Keep them updated on your application results
- Share how their support impacted your journey
🚫 Common Mistakes to Avoid
Even strong candidates sometimes stumble when it comes to recommendations. Here are some pitfalls to avoid:
1. Writing Your Own Letter
- Even if your recommender asks you to draft it
- This is generally considered unethical
- Could harm your application if discovered
2. Choosing the Wrong Recommenders
- Picking family friends with impressive titles
- Selecting professors from years ago who barely remember you
- Asking peers instead of supervisors
3. Poor Planning
- Waiting until the last minute
- Not providing enough context
- Failing to follow up appropriately
🤝 Need More Support?
Navigating graduate school applications can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to do it alone. At The Art of Applying®, we specialize in helping Wild Card applicants get into top graduate programs with significant scholarships.
Whether you need help:
- Choosing the right recommenders
- Crafting your recommender packet
- Managing the entire application process
- Securing scholarships to fund your education
We’re here to help! Book a Quick Call with our team to learn how we can support your graduate school journey.
Remember: Strong letters of recommendation aren’t just about having the right connections—they’re about strategically managing relationships and making it easy for your recommenders to advocate for you effectively. With the right approach, you can secure letters that will make your application shine.
Ready to take the next step? Book your Quick Call with our team today!
Leave a Reply